|

Menu

Speeches

The right to remain

Dr. Ernst Roets
25/09/2026

This speech was delivered by Dr Roets during the White Cross Project Conference on 25 September in Washington, D.C.

This building is not entirely foreign to South Africa. In 1987, ANC President Oliver Tambo stood here to explain his movement’s struggle and to make the case for international pressure and political change. Chris Hani spoke here 1991 as a member of the ANC’s National Executive Committee while serving as Deputy General Secretary of the South African Communist Party (SACP). Later that same year, Nelson Mandela came here to argue that the existing political order had to give way to a new one.

Today, more than three decades after the transition, it is appropriate to question how the political order that was established in the 1990s should be judged, how the expectations created in the 1990s compare with the realities currently experienced?

I want to start by sharing with you from the treasure chest that is Afrikaner culture. It’s a song by an artist called Chris Chameleon, called Om te Verdaag, which, if translated, means To Depart.

Loosely translated, the song goes as follows:

It was late at night and it was dark, when she woke me up and said:

I have to get far away from here.

I cannot keep living in fear.

I cannot keep going on like this behind closed doors.

My house has become a prison.

Are you coming with me, or will you allow me to leave you?

And she says: I love you dearly.

And all the fruits of my existence are yours if you come with me.

Can we start over before we lose everything and each other?

Let’s start over somewhere else.

I asked her if she could wait, wait for a new day.

So that I can think about my answer.

But when the African sun broke in the East.

I knew my answer very well.

And with a heavy heart, I informed her.

Because we all know that the truth can hurt.

And I said: I love you dearly.

And all the fruits of my existence are yours

But I cannot go with you.

Without my roots in the soil, I cannot bear fruit.

I cannot do what you ask of me.

And so she said to me: Then you have to stay behind alone.

This land has destroyed our love.

But this land is my mother,

This land is my father,

This land is my beloved.

The conflict described in this song is one that confronts countless people from our beautiful country. Many have chosen to leave. And the option to leave has been made easier, thanks to the U.S. government.

But, many have chosen to stay. I will stay. My colleagues here will stay. And millions more will stay. Most of those who chose to leave remain attached to the African sun and their roots in this beautiful country. Leaving should not be read as a sign of abandonment, of ruined conviction or of loss of commitment.

And that is what I want to talk about today: The Right to Remain.

Today, we will hear about incitement of violence against minorities. We will hear about farm attacks. We will hear about the exclusion through a vast network of race laws. We will hear about the threats to property rights.

We will also hear about why this is important to the United States of America. We will discuss what could be done about the crisis – in the short term, to alleviate the symptoms of a failing state entangled with minority persecution; but also in the long term, to promote a viable constitutional dispensation for the peoples of South Africa.

Several decades ago, South Africa was described as a miracle story. The world celebrated, and then looked away. And it has been turning a blind eye for decades. But today, the gap between perception and reality has become unbridgeable. South Africa has strayed so far away from the promises of Nelson Mandela – that the days of the gravy train are over, that there will be no fat cats, that crime will come down, that people will flourish, and that the country will never again experience the oppression of one group by another – that merely mentioning the failure of South Africa has become controversial.

We believe that the controversy is vested in the fact that reality forces people to confront their ideological preconvictions, and that there are too many people who choose the comfort of ideology above the nuisance of reality.

On Treason and Sovereignty

And so, when we criticise the South African government, the activists accuse us of treason and call for us to be prosecuted. When the U.S. government criticizes the South African government, they say that South Africa is a sovereign state, and that its sovereignty must be respected.

So let’s start with the elephant in the room – the sovereignty of the South African state.

Yes, in terms of international law, states are sovereign, and that sovereignty must be respected.

But sovereignty is not the only principle international law recognises.

The United Nations' 1970 Declaration on Friendly Relations – which was unanimously adopted by the General Assembly and remains highly celebrated by the ANC, affirms both sovereignty of states and the rights and self-determination of peoples. More important for our present purposes, the Declaration makes it clear that the protection of sovereignty is not without precondition. Sovereignty also depends on how the state in question treats its citizens. International Law explicitly states that the right to claim sovereignty and non-interference extends to states conducting themselves consistently with the principle of self-determination and possessing governments representing the whole people ‘without distinction as to race, creed or colour.’

We do not have the Right to Remain because it is enshrined in the Constitution. We have this right, because it is a self-evident, inalienable right of all peoples. A government’s right to sovereignty does not extend to the right to persecute.

The Right to Remain

Thomas Aquinas distinguished between what is just by nature and what is established by human agreement. He said that the written law does not give force to the natural right, because natural right derives its force from God and from nature, which preponderates legislation.

We are told that objecting to racial discrimination is invalid when it has been enacted into law. We are told that amending the Constitution to erode property rights renders objections to confiscation obsolete. We are told that if the Constitutional Court declares that it is acceptable for politicians to chant about the extermination of minorities, our moral frame of reference should adapt, evidently because our moral ontology should be shaped by what is written by judges even if they were appointed on the precondition that they promote the political program of those in power.

But written law is not the source from which justice springs. Law can recognise justice, protect justice and give institutional form to justice, but writing an injustice into law does not convert it into justice.

And it is in that sense that I speak about the Right to Remain.

It is the right to live in the place you call home without being forced to surrender the things that make it home. It is the ability to raise your children in your language, to preserve institutions that you inherited and institutions that you built, to acquire and retain property, to participate in public life without being reduced to a racial category, and to have some meaningful influence over the circumstances under which your community lives. In short, it is the right to autonomy over your own affairs.

Because we belong before we choose to belong.

None of us sat down at some rational moment before birth and selected our parents, our ancestors, our mother tongue, our history or the community into which we would be born. Yet, it is those things that give us meaning, and it is those things for which we are punished.

A political order that demands citizens to cooperate with policies that suppress their most basic freedoms; to be something that they are not; to allow themselves to be beaten into submission; is not a just political order.

The question that we need to answer is not whether South Africa will survive as a state as much as it is whether it will remain a home to which the peoples of the country can belong.

The structure beneath the symptoms

South Africa is not merely diverse in the superficial sense. It contains communities with profoundly different histories and, in some cases, substantially different understandings of property, authority, equality, community and the proper role of the state.

Yet for more than a century, this extraordinary diversity has consistently been governed through a political architecture in which enormous significance attaches to control of the national centre.

This is not simply an accusation against the ANC.

The British did not discover a sustainable way of governing the whole of South Africa from the centre. The Afrikaner government that followed did not discover one either.

In 1994 the franchise changed. The Constitution changed. The old order was abolished…

But the foundational pillar survived remarkably well: the conviction that an exceptionally large and diverse society should still have an exceptionally powerful political centre.

In that sense, the constitutional change essentially changed who controlled the centre.

The negotiators for a new South Africa did not sufficiently consider how much should be controlled from the centre in the first place. In the extent that they did, they certainly did not sufficiently consider whether those who would be in power would agree with their interpretation of the text.

That is why the conversation we are interested in is about moving beyond the central assumption that has survived all of those systems: excessive centralisation.

Our argument is not to return to the past. It is the opposite. It is to move beyond that which defined the political system in the past and that continues to define the system today.

The contradictions worth examining

Once we begin to look at South Africa through that lens, the contradictions become too obvious to ignore.

South Africa pursues non-racialism through race laws, empowerment through a system that entrenches state dependency, and equality through unequal treatment.

It celebrates diversity while pursuing homogenisation, it proclaims locality, while concentrating political power, it condemns imperialism, while suppressing self-government, it speaks endlessly of liberation while resisting the dispersal of power.

These are not mere contradictions of language. It reveals that a state founded in the name of freedom has become increasingly antagonistic to the basic principles of freedom.

What we are trying to build

The deeper question, then, is not simply whether South Africa will continue to exist as a state. The more important question is whether South Africa can remain a home to which people can belong.

Because we have the Right to Remain.

The Right to Remain without being required to reject who we are. The Right to Remain without surrendering our languages, our communities, our properties, our safety, our dignity or our hope for our children. The right to remain without being told that freedom is only an option somewhere else.

We have no hidden agenda. We seek peace, justice, mutual respect, inter-communal cooperation, freedom for individuals and families to make their own decisions in the pursuit of happiness, and freedom for the peoples of South Africa to run their institutions, to maintain the things that give them meaning… and a political order that does not prevent these things.