|

Menu

Speeches

Crossed Out: Confronting Persecution in South Africa

Dr. Ernst Roets
15/09/2026

This speech was delivered by Dr Roets during the first screening of Crossed Out: Confronting Persecution in South Africa on 15 September 2026

Crossed Out: Confronting Persecution in South Africa

Documentary Screening

Introduction Speech

There are moments in history when the world pays particular attention to a single country. There have been several moments when that country was South Africa.

First, with the establishment of a refreshment station at the Cape of Good Hope, which unlocked trading routes between the West and the East.

Then again, with the outbreak of the Anglo Boer War, and the Scorched Earth policy of the British Empire, leading to significant international support for the peoples of South Africa.

Then again in the aftermath of the Soweto Uprisings of 1976, when the Apartheid system was perceived to be at its peak, at its most powerful. At the time the world was very close to unified on the notion that the ANC and its allies had to be supported in its struggle against the White Minority Government.

That attention persisted throughout the early 1990s, through the negotiations for a 'New South Africa', culminating with the inauguration of Nelson Mandela as the President of South Africa. At his inauguration, Mandela declared that ‘Never, never and never again shall it be that this beautiful land will again experience the oppression of one by another’.

South Africa rejoiced. And so did the world.

When the 1996 Constitution was adopted, it was commonly described as the 'Final Constitution'.

It's remarkable that no-one calls it the 'Final Constitution' anymore. The ‘Final Constitution’ just became ‘the Constitution’. Describing it as such, suggesting that South Africa will never again experience significant political change was deeply naive, because the mean lifespan for written Constitutions throughout the world since 1789 – since the French Revolution – is just 17 years. In Africa it’s even less – just a little more than one decade. South Africa itself has had five Constitutions just in the last century. The country underwent significant constitutional change in 1910, 1961, 1983, 1993, and ‘finally’ in 1996.

Retrospectively, we should probably agree that there was something deeply presumptuous, something incredibly self-centered about the politics of the 1990s, which consistently seemed to suggest that, as a result of the Fall of the Berlin Wall and the conclusion of the Cold War, the world had reached, achieved, concluded the final answers.

In defense of South Africa's politicians and commentariat, the belief in 'finality', in final solutions, was not unique to South Africa during the 1990s.

  • The ‘Washington consensus’ believed that a new set of economic policy prescriptions constituted the one, final, and indisputable formula for economic prosperity that ought to be implemented across the globe.
  • Francis Fukuyama famously declared that the world seemed to have reached 'the End of History' – the final stage of human development. He even speculated that the future might be pretty boring, precisely because the quest for answers had largely been concluded.
  • The American President, George H.W. Bush announced that a New World Order had arrived – one in which the law of the jungle had been replaced by the rule of law, in which nations recognize that they have a shared responsibility, and in which the questions that a hundred generations have been grappling with, have finally been answered.
  • It was in this decade, when Thomas Friedman famously argued that no two countries with a McDonalds would ever go to war with each other, because global economic integration was believed to provide a permanent solution to international warfare.

The overarching conviction was that the combination of globalist ideology, liberal democracy, capitalism, economic integration, and the erosion of borders was on the verge of permanently solving the great questions of the ages.

And, what is particularly important for us, here in South Africa, is that the negotiations for a New South Africa transpired right in the middle of this global ballyhoo. This is in our analysis the single most important reason why most of the globe – and the Western world in particular – were so intimately involved with South African politics at the time. And they were not just involved. They prescribed solutions and incentivised specific outcomes.

Now, remember that South Africa is a big country. But it is not just big, it is exceptionally diverse. South Africa’s diversity extends beyond language differences. The country is inhabited not just by a variety of cultural communities, but a variety of civilizations as such.

There are many things on which we all agree: Murder is wrong, honesty is good, families are important, the government should be responsible and so forth. Even though we might not all abide by these beliefs, almost all of us would agree with it.

But there are also a lot of things on which we disagree fundamentally. This includes where the line ought to be drawn between free speech and hate speech, the significance of individual ownership of property as opposed to communal ownership, the proper definition of the type of equality that ought to be pursued, how the conflict between the pursuit of freedom and the pursuit of equality has to be responded to, the meaning of prosperity and the conditions required to achieve it, the nature and purpose of human rights, the supremacy of the Constitution, as opposed to, for example, the supremacy of God, our conception of self, and for our present purposes, most significantly, the role of the State.

These are not trivial things. But more importantly, many of these things do not have simple right or wrong answers. Many of them are the type of things in which disagreement is not just predictable, but one might even say, healthy.

This is why we value the words of N.P. van Wyk Louw, when he said that the circulation of ideas is as important for a community, as the circulation of blood flow is for the body. Now, contrary to popular belief, South Africa is not just one community. South Africa is a community of communities, a nation of nations.

This begs the question: How should one approach matters of constitutionalism for a country – or, dare I say – a region like South Africa?

The dominant thinking of the 1990s produced a peculiar approach to diversity: celebrate it culturally, but minimize its constitutional significance. Diversity could be expressed through food, language, festivals and private association, through individual choice to associate, but the political order itself would deal principally with the indictments as aa citizen of the central state.

This is why Roelf Meyer – at the time chief negotiator for the National Party, and currently an ANC member serving as ambassador to the United States – argued during the negotiations that the accommodation of cultural identity in a culturally diverse society is superfluous. Because, in Meyer’s analysis, it’s not necessary to protect communities if you have a strong state that recognises individuals as citizens. The argument was that communities consist of individuals, and that the community is protected if the individual is protected.

But Meyer’s conclusion was not an isolated one. It was merely an expression of the overwhelming zeitgeist of the time. But, there is an important difference between recognizing the right of the individual to participate in the cultural activities of his or her choice; and recognizing the right of the community to continue to exist and to maintain and manage its own institutions. The former is recognized in the South African political dispensation, the latter is not.

And so, the overwhelming global ideology of the time prescribed that the proper way to approach cultural diversity is to recognise it only to the extent to which it can be subverted to nothing more than an expression of individual choice under the watchful eye of the state. For example, you have a right to study in the language of your choice, if the institution that provides for it exists, but your community does not have a right to its own institutions – a language community, for example, does not have the right to educational institutions that provide education in their language.

That is why, the de facto operative logic of the South African political dispensation treats us primarily as untethered subjects of the State, under the presumption that the State will decide on our behalf what is good for us. Theoretically it’s compelling, but the problem is that it doesn’t work… because this is not how people think or behave.

This is why the Canadian philosopher Charles Taylor points to what he calls a lack of fit between what people consciously profess to believe and what they actually require in order to make sense of their moral convictions. Modern political language encourages us to describe ourselves primarily in universal terms: as individuals possessing equal rights and equal dignity. But our behaviour reveals something more complicated.

We do not value everything equally. A parent will sacrifice far more for his own children than for strangers. People are more deeply affected when their own language, culture or community is threatened. An Afrikaner will understandably feel farm murders more personally; a township resident will experience taxi violence in a more immediate way; a coloured community in the Cape may be especially concerned about gang violence.

This does not necessarily contradict the principle that every person possesses equal dignity. It simply reveals something about human nature that the political theories of the 1990s overlook: we are not merely citizens of the state. We are communal creatures. We belong before we choose to belong. We inherit languages, loyalties, histories and relationships, and these things become part of who we are, part of what we cherish.

Now… Why do I mention all of this? How is this at all related to the documentary film that we are releasing today?

The answer is simple. And let me close the loop…

South Africa is not working. In an earlier paper by Lex Libertas, we pointed out that the true extent of the crisis in South Africa could best be described under three categories. First, the country suffers under a destructive policy framework; second, the state is failing; and third, minorities are being persecuted. Of these, the third is the most disputed.

This is why we made Crossed Out. Not because exposing a problem is an alternative to proposing a solution, but because no serious solution can be built upon a false diagnosis. The film is therefore not intended as a verdict on South Africa. It is an invitation to reopen a conversation that the world prematurely believed had been concluded.

But, we believe that these categories are not the crisis in itself. Instead, they are symptoms of a deeper rooted crisis. That deeper rooted crisis sprouts from the fact that the political system is not aligned with reality.

The reality is that the country is large and diverse, and that the diversity of South Africa is not a trivial matter. But the political system rejects this diversity, and seeks to enforce conformity. It does this by signalling that there is something wrong with you if you value the things that make you who you are – that you are wrong to live according to your nature, to value your natural identity as a member of a cultural community. And so, we are told, for example, that if we were truly patriotic about South Africa, we would stop being Afrikaners, and we would participate in the political programme prescribed by those in power.

Love for country, we are told, should manifest in loyalty, and loyalty is presented as a synonym for obedience – not just obedience to the law, but obedience to the ideological prescriptions of those in power.

But this is not sustainable. This effectively means that our inherited communal identities – who we are by nature, as a result of our communal association – should make way for a new administrative civic identity – our identity as a citizen of a territorial state. The fact is that when an administrative civic identity is used to suppress inherited communal identities, resistance should not be surprising; precisely because it is predictable.

Now, to be blunt, we are not all Afrikaners here tonight, and at Lex Libertas, our support and our message extends far beyond Afrikaners. But it should be said that Afrikaners are not demanding the right to dominate. We are demanding the right not to be punished for being who we are. What Afrikaners are saying is: Stop waging war on us for being who we are. Stop the scapegoating. Stop the blameshifting. Stop using us as a political punching bag. Stop attacking our language. Stop assaulting our institutions. Stop ridiculing our culture. Stop tolerating, trivialising or excusing incitement of violence when it is directed at us. Stop pretending that when members of our community are murdered, that it’s either not happening, or it is less condemnable, less worthy of intervention, than when the victim was someone else.

And so, we believe that the root of the problem is disconnect from reality. The realities of South Africa have to bend the knee to ideological prescription. But once again, it’s not sustainable. It’s not working, and it will not work. The predictable outcome is failure and conflict.

The heart of the problem, as far as we are concerned, is excessive centralization. This means the core of the solution is decentralization and self-governance. Political authority should be brought down and closer to the communities that live under the consequences of political decisions. Because when political power is centralized as extremely as it is in a country that is as diverse as South Africa, the natural consequence is that there is no accountability, that politicians become untouchable. And also, that everything – every societal issue – depends on who wins the election.

This necessarily facilitates inter-communal conflict, governance through sloganeering and a destructive tribalism. It brings out the worst in people, because it suppresses what is true and what is good.

If we truly love South Africa, if we truly carry the interests of not just our own communities, but the communities of South Africa, at heart, then we should all rally behind this idea: Bring government down to the people, give the peoples of this country more self-governance.

A centralised political order that shields political elites from accountability harms every community under its authority. Indeed, the greatest victims are most probably impoverished black communities trapped between dependence on the state and the consistent failure of that same state.

The 1990s were not final. We should not confuse the end of one chapter with the end of history. Thirty years ago, many believed that South Africa's great political question had finally been answered. History, as it turned out, had other plans. And now, after three decades, the world is paying attention to South Africa again.

Every generation inherits a question it did not choose, but cannot avoid. Thirty years ago, one generation answered theirs. Ours is different: Do we have the courage to recognize, to admit that many of the conclusions we believed to be true were in fact misleading?

And: Are we prepared to pursue a political order grounded in recognition of reality and mutual respect despite differences, that can allow the peoples of South Africa to live freely, securely and peacefully alongside one another?

We will not answer that question by clinging to the deceptive comfort of a previous generation. We will answer it by confronting reality as it is, by recovering the truth, the goodness and the beauty that ideology taught us to ignore, and by having the courage to pursue these things despite adversity.

Crossed Out is our invitation to reopen that conversation.

Thank you.